What Is Sequence of Returns Risk?
Why the Order of Returns Matters
Sequence of returns risk is the danger that the market's bad years show up early in retirement, while you are also taking money out. The average return can be identical and the outcome still very different, because withdrawals during a downturn leave less invested to recover. It matters most in the years just before and after you stop working.
What does “sequence of returns” actually mean?
It means the order in which good and bad years arrive. Over a long time the average is what most people look at, but when you are taking money out, the order matters as much as the average.
A simple example
Take two retirees who each start with $1,000,000 and withdraw $50,000 at the start of each year. Over three years, both get the same three returns: a 20% loss, a flat year, and a 20% gain. The only difference is the order.
| Retiree A: loss first | Retiree B: gain first | |
|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $950,000 after withdrawal, then -20% = $760,000 | $950,000 after withdrawal, then +20% = $1,140,000 |
| Year 2 | $710,000 after withdrawal, then 0% = $710,000 | $1,090,000 after withdrawal, then 0% = $1,090,000 |
| Year 3 | $660,000 after withdrawal, then +20% = $792,000 | $1,040,000 after withdrawal, then -20% = $832,000 |
Same average return, same withdrawals, and Retiree B finishes $40,000 ahead. Retiree A took money out of a smaller account at the worst moment, so there was less left to recover. Stretch that over 25 or 30 years and the gap can be the difference between a comfortable retirement and an uncomfortable one. This is an illustration with round numbers, not a forecast.
Why does it hit hardest around retirement?
Because that is when your balance is biggest and you switch from adding money to taking it out. A loss on a large balance, plus a withdrawal on top of it, is the combination that does the damage. While you are still saving, the same downturn works in your favor, since each contribution buys more.
What can you do about it?
None of these removes the risk, but each one softens it:
- Keep a reserve. Holding a year or two of spending in cash or stable investments means you are not forced to sell stocks during a decline.
- Cover the essentials with income that does not move with the market. Social Security, a pension, and some annuities can pay the basic bills. (Annuity guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuer.) Should I Take Social Security at 62, 67 or 70? and Guaranteed Income cover the options.
- Stay flexible. Trimming withdrawals a little in a down year, and taking a little extra in a good one, helps a lot over time.
- Think about it before you retire. The five years on either side of your retirement date are when this matters most, so it is the right time to test your plan against a bad start.
Test it on your own numbers
Whether your plan can handle a rough first few years depends on your accounts, your spending and your other income. We are glad to run that with you by virtual appointment, at no cost and no obligation. If you want to see where you stand first, Am I Ready to Retire? is a good place to start.
Nothing on this page is a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security, or advice about your particular situation. All investing involves risk, including loss of principal.
Quick answers
- What is sequence of returns risk?
- The risk that the order of investment returns hurts you even when the average return is fine. If markets fall early in retirement while you are withdrawing money, you sell more shares at low prices, and there is less left to benefit when markets recover.
- Does it matter while I am still saving?
- Much less. While you are adding money, a downturn means you buy at lower prices. The risk is concentrated in the years just before and just after you start withdrawing.
- How do I protect against it?
- Common approaches are keeping a reserve for the next year or two of spending, covering essential expenses with income that does not depend on the market, staying flexible about how much you withdraw in a bad year, and spreading investments sensibly. None of these removes the risk entirely.
- Is a bad market early in retirement a disaster?
- Not by itself. It makes the plan less forgiving, which is why it helps to have thought through the response in advance rather than in the middle of a downturn.